Offers and pay

Should you accept the first offer?

I used to make job offers. The first number was rarely the highest we could pay. Here’s what to do in the moment between “we’d like to offer you” and “yes.”

The short version
  1. Don’t say yes on the spot
    Thank them and ask for the offer in writing.
  2. Check it against the market
    And against what you need.
  3. Ask once, politely, with a reason
    Most offers have some room.

What the person making the offer knows

When a company makes an offer, it has usually planned a range for the role. The first number is often not the top of that range, because many companies expect some candidates to negotiate. Plenty of people never ask, and they start at a lower salary than they could have had.

That difference doesn’t stay small. Future raises are often a percentage of your current salary, so a lower starting point can follow you for years. Try the free Cost of Not Asking calculator to see what it adds up to.

What to say in the moment

Thank them, show you’re excited, and ask for the full offer in writing with a day or two to review it. That’s a completely normal request, and it stops you from saying yes to a number you haven’t checked.

How to ask for more

1

Restate your interest

Make clear you want the job.

2

Give a specific number

Not “more”, an actual figure, with a short reason.

3

Stop talking

Let them respond. Silence is part of negotiating.

Keep it to one clear ask: gratitude first, a specific number backed by your research, then let them answer. The exact words for the ask, and for what to say if they come back with “this is our best offer”, are in the 5-Day Pay Sprint and in Salary Negotiation Scripts.

And if the salary truly can’t move, the rest of the package often can.

Can asking lose the offer?

It’s rare when you ask politely, once, with a reasonable number. The company has already invested a lot in choosing you.

Start free →

Free: 3 salary answers that work

Word-for-word answers to “What are your salary expectations?”, from the 5-Day Pay Sprint. About 15 minutes.

Get it free
Talking money soon?

Know your number. Say it with confidence.

The 5-Day Pay Sprint walks you through researching your number, answering the salary question and negotiating the offer or a raise, with word-for-word scripts. Or start with the free calculator to see what not asking really costs.